12 Comments
Jan 19Liked by Christine Greenwald

Both my grandfathers were “holiness revivalist preachers. My father was a parish pastor in a “holiness” fundamentalist church. I was steeped in an environment that included religious/spiritual terrorism. I want to say, Christine, that the work you are doing is so important. Thank you. Keep going.

Expand full comment
Jan 19Liked by Christine Greenwald

That movie was on my list and I completely forgot about it. So relatable, and such a hard thing for a kid to understand. (In our case) why do my loving grandparents say unloving things in the name of religion? It’s very hard to hold my inner kid and my actual kids at the same time 💔

Expand full comment
Jan 19Liked by Christine Greenwald

I have had adult clients going through “unloving actions in the name of religion “ and it has broken my heart. Saw the movie on the plane to Rome, where I confronted how much Roman wealth came from plundering assets held by Jews. Yup, if I had kids, I would have a hard time explaining the rigidity of religious dogma to them, much less justifying it.

Expand full comment
Jan 19Liked by Christine Greenwald

I want to see this. I love the book. And YES I feel the shift this year.

Expand full comment

I haven't seen the movie, but what you wrote about it is so relatable. It brings home the fact that so many of the things we fight about, debate about, and disagree about in different religious traditions are actually very basic things that any kid can understand. Like, we should love each other. And, people shouldn't do awful things to each other in the name of religion. Or, if God is good, he wouldn't do something like... *name your traumatizing belief of choice.* I think true "religion" is actually simple enough for children to understand, and we'd all do well to learn from the kids in our lives.

P.S., I feel a "shift" too - Personally, a lot of life circumstances are coming together for me, and I'm feeling a lot more hope and joy this year. If it's not too cringe to include a Bible verse here, it feels unexpectedly like Romans 8:28 - God working all things together for good. :)

Expand full comment

I loved the Are You There, God? movie too!

Expand full comment

I haven't seen this yet but I'm adding it to our next family movie night. Also, I've tossed around doing a virtual support group around the podcast from the Holy/Hurt podcast. Hit me up if you'd be interested in talking about collaborating.

Expand full comment